Ben’s partner had been back for three days, and he was still waiting for him to come home.
‘Home’ was vaguely defined for him at this point. He had moved in with Jake three months ago and the change felt stifling. Change was what Ben needed, without any question, but that didn’t make the transition any easier.
Jake lived exactly like someone would assume a man like him lived: he looked like a lumberjack and he committed to the bit entirely. His house was more like a cabin, nestled in close to the woods, and while there were several other little country homes scattered around the road, actual ‘civilization’ and stores were a good forty-five minutes away. As picturesque as it all sounded, Ben wasn’t adjusting well.
He didn’t know how to phrase it without sounding snooty or spoiled. He wasn’t opposed to country life, but he felt isolated. He was used to just stepping outside for a coffee to get himself moving, experiencing a basic human interaction over something as simple as checking out a library book, or window shopping to occupy his anxious mind. Here, anything like that required a very committed trek back and forth, which seemed indulgent when he could brew coffee at home or save all his errands for a weekend. So, he cooped himself up indoors, and inadvertently stuck himself into a self-fulfilling prophecy: he would be less stressed if he went outside, but going outside made him stressed, repeat ad nausem.
It was a fine for someone like Jake, who lived and breathed the outdoors. He’d been at it since he was young; scaling the mountain that lorded over the town the same way other kids climbed monkey bars. He showed Ben everything he knew with a quiet enthusiasm, never making him feel foolish for how city life made him soft. He laughed (but not unkindly) when Ben tried to wear his sneakers and took him shopping for hiking boots instead. He politely corrected Ben’s first attempt at foraging by pointing out which mushrooms he could take home to cook and which would leave him on his back. He even spent a good week diligently rubbing aloe into Ben’s aching skin when he stupidly neglected to reapply his sun block.
Relative naivety aside, Ben liked the wilderness well enough. They’d take little camping trips or walks together, but he very obviously slowed Jake down. Despite insistence that he didn’t mind, Ben was perfectly aware that he was interrupting an established routine of rising with the sun and hiking until a normal person would collapse from exhaustion.
So, there was another circle: he felt guilty asking his partner to stop doing what made him happy, so he let Jake do his hikes alone, but in his absence Ben felt nagging nerves regardless.
He knew he was putting a lot on Jake. He had no other connections here, moving two cities over was equally about running to Jake as it was running from someone else. He didn’t want to call himself a coward, but when his ex would keep showing up at his apartment, trying to make amends, and Jake had to drive an hour to intervene more than once—
So, Jake made an offer: Ben could move in. There was plenty of space. There would be no more unwelcome guests at his apartment. They practically spent all their time together anyway, and it would save on the gas. The countryside was gorgeous and Ben worked from home, anyway. It also put him far out of his ex’s reach.
“Don’t worry,” Jake promised. “I’m going to take care of you.”
On paper, it sounded perfect. It should’ve been — but Ben turned agoraphobic and anxious and annoying.
He was perfectly aware of how annoying he was. Jake had to deal with his misplaced fears and anxieties about the outdoors. He soothed Ben as much as he could with simple facts: Jake had been living here all of his life, and never had an issue on any of his hikes; he knew how to keep himself safe. Ben was inclined to believe him, but on a paranoid nosedive online, he discovered that a local woman — Evie Pearson — who also lived and breathed these woods went missing without a trace three months prior… and it was all downhill from there.
“Accidents happen,” Jake admitted when Ben brought it up, “even when you know what you’re doing.”
Jake was quiet in a way that betrayed his own unease with the subject — the disappearance of a woman he must have known — and so Ben dropped it right away, but the fear took root: that means even you, it yelled in Ben’s head, that means it can happen to you too!
Ben never admitted how the woods changed for him after that. He pictured the mouths of caves as hungry maws, the jagged branches as clawing fingers, and feared falling down the river would be too akin to sliding down a greedy gullet. In absence of any real predator, his mind invented one at every opportunity, turning the woods themselves into some strange monster.
Ben told his mind to settle and it never would. Jake would leave for a hike and the minute he was a little later than usual, Ben would imagine all the different ways he could have tripped or fallen or been eaten by something lurking in the trees. He would think about how utterly incapable he would be of tracking him down and how he would probably just end up lost alongside him. He would spiral on like this until Jake walked in the door, bright and sunny as usual, and Ben pretended he hadn’t spent the last half hour imagining him dying. Because that was ridiculous.
Until the day came that Jake didn’t come back.
Ben reasoned with himself for the first hour or two. Then, it hit noon and he tried to call his phone — a useless endeavour and he knew it, given the lack of service in the woods. He still made the effort, which obviously earned him nothing. He tried to find an excuse, thinking himself paranoid. It was when the sun started to set that real, unbridled panic set in.
He called the local police, who were less than insightful. Ben doubted his nervous stammering helped his cause. Jake had a reputation as an outdoorsman, like he practically sprouted out of the woods like some old oak tree, and they figured he just decided to camp overnight.
“Why would he do that without telling me?” Ben countered, which didn’t sway them at all, and the unspoken insinuation was clear: maybe because he needed a break from you.
He knew Jake was adored here. This community was small and everyone knew everyone. So, the introduction of Ben: an anxious mess with his nose in his computer all the time, reading weird books and making even weirder art… it didn’t slide well. Jake was the most eligible bachelor here, and they looked at Ben like they couldn’t believe they lost such a prime piece of real estate to him.
The same ‘weird’ art that earned Ben more than his fair share of odd looks was what made Jake introduce himself. While he didn’t look like the sort who would drive into the city to admire an amateur art gallery, he was there the first time Ben put something on, striking up a conversation so shyly that it didn’t suit the sheer size of him.
Ben didn’t think he made a good impression, but something kept Jake coming back to the next show, and the next. Ben couldn’t tell if it was himself or the art that got Jake’s attention, but it hurt more than he expected to turn down the invitation to get a coffee. At that point, he was still seeing Shane — and he didn’t think they were overheard, but the temper that came home with him that night proved Ben wrong.
Stupid as it made him feel, Ben tried to take things into his own hands. Realistically, he knew social media was a wild goose chase, but he still posted Jake’s picture and wrote about how he hadn’t come home from his morning hike. It was ridiculous, as if anyone else might’ve bumped elbows with him through the huge landscape of the forest, but it made him feel a little less useless. Again, due to Jake’s popularity, the message did circulate, but no one miraculously saw him in the middle of the woods that day. It reached further than he expected — and even Shane lit up his phone, on a new account that hadn’t been blocked.
I’m so sorry about Jake, he wrote, please let me know if I can do anything.
You can fuck off, Ben thought but he didn’t have the nerve to text, and sobbed more than he slept.
Jake showed up in the middle of the night. Ben jerked awake to find him in the doorway, dirty and distant, and Ben threw himself on his unmoving bulk in a blabbing mess. He couldn’t be coherent. It was probably a jumble of: where were you; I was so worried about you; you’re so stupid; what happened; you scared the shit out of me; I’m sorry; where were you; where were you?
Jake didn’t answer. No laughter or sunny reassurance. He just swallowed Ben up in his arms and collapsed on their bed together, not bothering to remove his boots.
Now, it had been three days, and Jake was still quiet and withdrawn. Ben tried to give him time. He made his favourite meals, though Jake barely touched them. He tried to give him ample space, but Jake still left in the night to sleep on the couch by himself instead. He didn’t pry. He tried to balance attentiveness with an appropriate space to breathe. It didn’t matter. Jake was withdrawn, quiet, and utterly unlike himself.
It was fine, though, Ben told himself. Jake was exhausted by… whatever happened and now he just needed time to recuperate. Maybe it wounded his pride to have gotten lost. Maybe… Ben didn’t know. There wasn’t a scratch on him and he didn’t say a word about it. He barely said a word about anything at all.
So today, when Jake’s name flashed on his phone, Ben jumped. He barely spoke when spoken to the last three days, and initiating a phone call was either progress or a disaster. Ben had been making dinner when he realized they were out of milk. Despite Ben’s concerns, Jake offered to go to the grocery store. Given his odd, sullen disposition, Ben didn’t like the idea of him going alone, but he already had his car keys and Ben didn’t want to fight potential improvement by shutting him down.
“Hey,” Ben greeted, unable to help a shake in his voice: feigning casual. “What’s up?”
Jake didn’t answer right away. There was nothing but the steady, slow sound of his breathing before his voice finally came through: deep and oddly subdued. “I can’t remember what milk you like.”
His shoulders sank. This was another strike against Ben in this community: whiny and too good to eat a piece of meat. Jake never fussed about it; he liked all the meals Ben prepared, and he made a point to keep himself involved—including remember what brands to use. Except now he couldn’t and he sounded hollow, if not ashamed. He imagined Jake: huge, burly, and bearded, standing like a lost child in front of a display of vegan milk substitutes, and he felt miserable.
“It’s the one with the red label,” Ben said, weighing his risks before he added. “Remember?”
Silence answered him and Ben swallowed against tension in his throat. “Sometimes it’s out of stock,” he said, if just to break the silence. It moved off the shelves since it was the best one, in Ben’s opinion — an opinion he stole from Shane, actually, but he squashed that thought as quickly as it came.
He kept thinking about Shane; like the stupid text cut him and left a wound, stinging too often to be ignored. Shane knew exactly what he was doing: pretending to be kind and well-intentioned, but with his own selfish motive. He always acted like the most thoughtful, kind person in the world; that was why everyone loved him and couldn’t imagine why Ben left him. Shane supported his dismal little art career; he had all the community connections and put him up in galleries that he was not qualified for; he took him to expensive places and toured him all around town on his dime.
Everyone thought Ben was crazy to give that up and go live with Jake. Jake probably couldn’t spell hors d’oeuvres, let alone afford the price of them at Shane’s favourite restaurants. All of his friends were tied up with Shane; and they all expected he would see reason and come back eventually.
Ben did admit that it sounded easier to go back, now more than ever, with Jake’s distance and the cabin’s isolation closing in on him. Then, abruptly, he would remember the nasty, unpredictable edge of Shane’s temper. Ben was always blamed for setting him off. Shane snapped, smashed Ben’s computer in half, and all their friends wondered what he could’ve done to make nice, charming, funny Shane act like that.
Focus. Ben cleared his throat. “Did you find it?’
“I got it,” Jake stated levelly, and Ben expected him to disconnect, but he stayed on the line: breathing steadily in and out.
“Do you… need anything else?” Ben asked cautiously.
“No,” Jake admitted, quiet and submissive, but he still didn’t hang up.
“Okay,” Ben said, wetting his lips. “Okay, baby. I’ll see you soon?”
He offered the endearment like a consolation and maybe it worked, since Jake finally disconnected, and Ben exhaled shakily. He regretted sending him out there. Ben, of all people, with his nerves and his fears, should know how daunting a public space could be when you’re feeling vulnerable.
When he came home, Ben beamed at the sight of him. Jake handed him the milk outright, which Ben accepted with an easy smile, but he couldn’t help noticing the extra bags in his hand. “My hero,” he teased, and Jake didn’t seem to even hear him. Usually, his stupid little comments made Jake red in his ears, but now…
Ben turned back to the stove, waiting as Jake unloaded the rest of the groceries he picked up. Everything belonged in the fridge, it seemed, and Ben did his best to seem disinterested. Jake finished, retreating from the kitchen, and Ben waited until he was fully out of sight before he pried.
Jake had filled the fridge with meat: huge, bloody slabs, wet and swelling against their plastic seals. There was far too much of it, occupying every spare inch of their tiny fridge, and Ben felt dizzy.
Ben never asked Jake to change his diet for him. Jake insisted that he didn’t mind: he liked the idea of it, for the sake of the animals, but admitted he wasn’t enough of a cook to manage the lifestyle. Ben was more than happy to swoop in with his expertise, and Jake told him more than once that he couldn’t believe the meals he made. He would offer praise between huge mouthfuls and whenever Ben asked, he insisted he didn’t miss his old habits one bit.
As Ben hovered in front of the open fridge, wasting electricity and feeling woozy, his phone buzzed in his pocket. Mechanically, he looked at the text preview, and sighed at Shane’s name.
I heard Jake was found safe. I’m glad. I hope you don’t think I’m lying. Seriously, I’m really happy he wasn’t hurt.
The problem was, Ben wasn’t sure that was entirely true.
Ben didn’t bring it up. Neither of them ate dinner: Ben out of nerves and Jake out of the same sullen disconnect that hung over him since he came home. When he thought about it, he wasn’t sure how Jake was functioning: he picked at his food like a bird and barely took two bites.
“Is it bad?” Ben asked, and when Jake silently shook his head, he pushed. “It’s just… you usually like it when I cook for you.”
Jake only shrugged and it made him feel pathetically small.
Ben spent the whole night debating if he should ask, or pry. Was he being stupid? Did Jake maybe hit his head and all this oddity was some sort of… concussion or something? He forgot about the milk; did he forget about the meat? It didn’t really make sense, but stranger things had happened, right?
Ben left it alone. Tomorrow, he decided, he would ask a few questions to gauge his frame of mind, and then he would try to convince him to get checked out by a doctor. That way, Ben could convince him to leave immediately, and not risk him getting cold feet overnight.
Tonight, Ben spooned tight around him in bed, and he felt Jake flinch. The reaction churned miserably in his gut. Rather than recoil, he clung tighter as if to win him over by sheer determination. Jake didn’t move, so he tried to take that as a victory — but he also didn’t stay for very long.
He lingered a little, presumably waiting for Ben to fall asleep. Ben felt too sticky and ashamed to admit that he was still awake, letting Jake go without a fight. It wasn’t until the door closed that he sat up, scowling into the dark, and he chewed the inside of his lip.
He couldn’t stay like this. Staying like this with Shane almost killed him. Jake wasn’t like that, but something was wrong, and he had to stop acting like a coward.
Throwing the covers back, Ben left the bedroom with uncharacteristic determination. He would coax him off the couch, and they would talk. Jake wasn’t like Shane. Jake was a good person. They could talk and then everything would be fine.
Jake wasn’t on the couch, but the kitchen light was on.
Ben’s skin felt clammy, a strange dread itching up the back of his neck, and he nudged the door open with his elbow.
Jake was on his knees in front of the open fridge, hunched over a mess of bones and bloody plastic. He held a slab of red, raw steak between his fingers, pulling it off the bone with his teeth. He chewed, open mouthed, panting as if drowning for air, barely finishing one bite before scrambling for another. He groped desperately through the fridge, sending packages tumbling to the floor around him, as he seized another and ripped it open. He tore pieces off with his bare hands, shoving them past his lips alongside the mouthful he had barely given time to chew. As if his body could not keep up with the demand of his appetite, he shovelled more and more under his teeth, staining his beard wet and red.
Spittle and blood tangled together in a foamy, sick squelch as his jaw worked. His teeth skidded off slippery tendon, too blunt to find purchase, so he dug in harder, snapping wet tissue and swallowing with a ragged moan that sounded like relief. Evolution denied him sharp canines and jagged claws, so the work demanded strain that made his every motion frantic. The thought pushed in on Ben’s mind in odd dissonance: you’re not a predator; you’re not built for this.
Ben made a noise that he could not define as one single sound. It wasn’t powerful enough for a scream. It was a mangled, shocked, defeated sort of thing; a strangled croak of broken disbelief. Jake heard him, whipping his head up to meet his gaze: his face a bloody mess and his eyes ringed with tears.
Ben ran.
As fast as he could move, he ran back into the bedroom and slammed the door. Fumbling with shaking hands, he turned the lock and he realized he was moaning under his breath — the sound rising into a shout when Jake’s voice came from the other side of the door.
“Ben,” he gasped, “Ben, please…”
“No,” Ben answered miserably, unsure of what he was saying ‘no’ to, exactly. He shook his head feebly, grabbing tight on the doorknob, even though Jake hadn’t even bothered to try to open it.
“Ben. Please, I was trying… I didn’t know what else to do.”
“What does that mean?” Ben demanded, his voice choking as his pulse thudded in his ears.
“Ben,” he repeated, and Ben wished he would stop saying his name. “I… Listen. I found Evie.”
Ben froze. At first, the name didn’t break through his panic enough to register. Somewhere, through his hammering heart, the thought connected: Evie Pearson, the woman who went missing in the woods, who Jake knew and mourned—
“She found me,” Jake corrected, “and she was… she wasn’t right.”
Ben almost laughed at the sheer absurdity. How could she be? That had been three months ago – long enough for everyone to give up hope and make peace with it; long enough for them to bury an empty box.
“She’s dead.”
“She wasn’t,” Jake insisted. “She just looked sick and upset, and I didn’t understand – I… I don’t know. I wanted to help her.”
Because that’s who Jake was; Jake was a hero who tried to help dead women, and yet Ben was desperately searching the room for something heavy enough to barricade the door against him.
“She wouldn’t tell me what happened. I tried—I kept trying but she would scream at me if I got too close. I think—Ben, I think something else found her before I did, and I don’t know.”
Jake’s voice broke, fading into a quiet mantra: I don’t know, I don’t know… carried in the low timbre of his voice, thinning out into a miserable whine unlike Ben had ever heard from his throat before. Ben could picture him on the other side of the door: his forehead pressed against the wood, his hands painting it red.
“I wanted to help, but she kept saying… she said she couldn’t go home yet. She couldn’t until she figured out how to make it stop. She said—she said she didn’t think she could stomach it.”
Jake trailed off and Ben’s throat felt tight. Jake barely said five words at a time since he came back home and now he was babbling like he couldn’t stop.
“I don’t think she wanted to hurt me; I think she couldn’t help it.”
Stop, Ben entreated miserably, but the word didn’t make it to his lips. You’re not making any sense.
“I think she was… living off of things in the woods. That’s why she stayed there. So she wouldn’t pass it to anyone else. She said—please, Ben—she said if she ate someone, then it would stop, but she didn’t have the nerve to do it.”
Ben’s knees gave out. He sunk his weight against the door and he listened uselessly as Jake continued.
“I just thought she wasn’t thinking right. She’d been lost for so long, you know?” Jake rambled. “When I touched her, she attacked me. I got away but I think… Ben, whatever got into her, it got into me, and I don’t want to hurt you either.
“I didn’t understand what she meant. I came home, and I’m so hungry it hurts. It hurts and nothing fills it. I don’t know what to do.”
That was the disconnect; that was the flinch when Ben touched him; that was Jake thinking about tearing into his flesh like ripping bloody meat from the bone.
“I’m trying, Ben,” he pleaded. “I’m sorry.”
Ben barely heard him. Something had infected Jake. Something took Evie Pearson and made her rabid, and she passed it along. Jake wanted to devour him; he wanted to rip him apart with his bare hands and eat him raw.
Abandoning the door, Ben stumbled his way to the nightstand. Grabbing his phone with shaky hands, he did what everyone expected him to do eventually:
He texted Shane.
It took an hour for him to arrive. Ben crept out of the bedroom window and waited for him on the porch: arms squeezed tight around himself. Jake didn’t try to follow him, and Ben barely heard him moving inside—which was probably for the best. He swallowed back against his anxiety and rose to his feet.
Shane was smiling when he got out of his car. Given the gravity of the text, Ben figured he’d at least pretend to be concerned, but apparently he couldn’t help looking pleased with himself.
“Took you long enough,” Shane teased. “Just had to make me wait for it, huh?”
He didn’t have the energy to play along. “Can you come inside?” he asked, sounding hollow and unlike himself. “I wanna get my things.”
Shane nodded. Eager to play hero, he went in first, and that suited Ben fine. He followed behind him, trying to ignore the nausea swelling up in his gut. When they reached the living room, he picked up his laptop, trying to ignore the way his hands shook, watching the corners of the room for movement.
“Remember when this was the other way around?” Shane asked, watching him with an easy grin. “You had your big bodyguard watch me while you packed up all your stuff? You made me feel like a monster, you know. Over one little fight.”
Ben paused, the words cutting through his haze like a knife, and he narrowed his eyes. “One little fight?” he parroted.
“Yes, Benjamin,” Shane scoffed, with far too familiar mockery. “One little fight. You’re a mess to deal with, you know. It’s not exactly easy putting up with your bullshit every day, and I hit my limit. You made the one bad thing I ever did to you seem so unforgivable, but you already have a new computer. Are you going to hold that against me forever? I think I deserve some leniency after how much work I put into taking care of you.”
Ben said nothing. He felt nothing. He looked at Shane in his stupid, chiselled face: so self-assured and unconcerned, and he felt nothing.
Ben used to draw a line in his mind: if anyone he ever dated laid hands on him, he would end it. Shane, even at his most furious, did no such thing—which was why Ben made excuses for the other outbursts: a thrown phone, a broken wine glass, a kick against the bumper of his car. Of all the encounters that set Shane off, the laptop had been the most innocuous. Shane wanted to go out, but Ben was working, so he told him to go on ahead without him.
Shane didn’t like that.
One moment the keys were under his fingers, and the next they were scattered in little pieces on the floor. Shane exploded about a lack of gratitude, about disrespect, and Ben was too shocked to do anything but apologize on sheer, horrified instinct.
Like prey frozen in front of a predator.
Shane smiled at him now, and Ben noticed for the first time how sharp his teeth looked.
“I guess not,” he said flatly.
Satisfied, Shane turned away from him again, and Ben took the opportunity to smash his laptop across the side of his head.
Shane stumbled, swore, clutching at his skull in a fixture of shock and fury. “What the fuck?” he snarled, and Ben’s heartbeat raced.
Shock worked in his favour: Shane was too stunned, spitting vulgarity and accusations, and Ben lashed out again. He brought the computer down, over and over, and until a corner of the cracking frame connected against his temple with just the right amount of pressure, and Shane’s body crumpled down beneath him. Ben stood over him, his chest heaving in laboured breaths, and his arms shook. Grip failing, he let the laptop clatter to the floor, and choked on his voice as he called out.
“Jake?”
An answer came in the form of a hunched figure in the hallway. Tentatively, Jake showed himself, and Ben spoke to him like a skittish animal.
“Hey, it’s okay,” he said softly, offering a hollow laugh. “You usually like when I make you food, right?”
Having been granted permission, Jake descended without another word. Jake put his mouth on the weeping wound in Shane’s skull and moaned with something like relief—the sound quickly pitching lower, rougher, as he dug in with his hands and his teeth. As he dropped to his knees, setting on his meal with a sheer abandon, Ben fell too: sinking to the floor and watching with a disbelieving smile.
Cautiously, a tremor shaking up his arm, Ben reached out and touched the crown of his head. Jake startled, his eyes wide and his face stained red, and Ben responded with a soft hush with his exhale. His smile spread wider as he slid his fingertips along Jake’s cheek, smearing blood like crude makeup. He looked ashamed—scared in a way he didn’t recognize—and Ben smoothed his hand back through his sweat-damp hair: soft and reassuring.
“Don’t worry,” Ben told him. “I’m going to care take of you.”
Vincent West is an emerging trans author with a keen interest in fantasy, horror, and romance. A writer since childhood, Vincent lives in Ontario, Canada, with his partner and pets. He can be found on Twitter as @VWestWrites.