Let me tell you about a time in the mid-eighties. I was a kid, seven or eight, not much more. There was half a dozen of us who hung around together. Most hours after school and days upon days during summer holidays were spent roaming our street and beyond. We would walk until we got tired and stop, hoping some busy-body pain in the arse wouldn’t move us on.
Every day we would wander until we had to go back home, our meandering pilgrimages of nonsense. Every day but a Sunday. Sunday was church day. We were unusual amongst our peers in that one or both of our parents insisted on taking us to church on a Sunday morning. We had plenty of other Catholic friends, but our parents were the most strict about getting us there every week. Some kids never even went on Christmas and were sometimes shamed by our teachers. We were the ones who were mocked in the playground after for being such suck-ups, as though it was our choice.
There was nothing special about us. We weren’t kids who were going to achieve remarkable lives beyond what west Central Scotland offered, although television and films had put those ideas into our heads. Our time was filled with talk. Chattering about our hopes, other children, and fabrications. Chris was the one who told most lies, every day he said something outlandish and self-aggrandising while flashing his grin of huge teeth. Nick, of dark hair and soulful eyes, the smartest of us, would often call out the lies, starting an argument. The rest of us were less prone to lying, but not immune, we would all sneak in some achievement we couldn’t possibly have managed. Barry did it the least, which is amazing as he had the most reason to want the world different to what it was. He was the quietest and the one to face the world at its harshest.
So, it came as a huge surprise when he made the suggestion.
“We should not go to church this Sunday,” he said in the middle of the rest of us talking about football. He sat on the ground, trying to make his lanky frame much smaller, even in the relative safety of our company.
We gaped at him and the audacity of the idea. Missing church was almost impossible to imagine. I don’t think any of us knew what the world was like when Sunday morning wasn’t taken up by being there. My head swam with the alien idea.
“That’s stupid,” Nick said. “It’s really stupid. We have to get up early and go with our parents.”
“Not that early,” Barry said, his voice quiet but brimming with conviction. It was the first I had seen how intense he was, before I even had the vocabulary to describe it.
Stevie, the smallest of us who spent most of his time trying to get away from his younger sister, said, “Mum makes sure we’re up at six on a Sunday.”
“That’s great,” said Edward, the heavier kid whose mother was fine with us all being in her house all at once. “You get to see all the cartoons.”
“She doesn’t let us watch TV. She puts the radio on and if we want to do anything we have to read the Bible.”
“That’s fine. We can all get up early and say we’re going to the half eight service,” Barry said.
We had all been aware in a peripheral sense that there was an earlier service to the one we all attended. Having it as an option to avoid church completely was a revelation. It was tantalising and dangerous.
“Can we do that?” Edward said.
“Maybe,” Nick said, sounding doubtful.
“My cousin did it for ages,” Barry said, becoming more animated.
“Stevie’s mother’s not going to let him go without Wendy,” Edward said.
“Wendy won’t want to go. She just wants to go with mum,” Stevie said.
“What about grownups?” said Nick. “I think my mum and dad will want someone to go with us.”
“They might want Jeanette to go with us,” Edward said, talking about his older sister as though she was some horrendous ogre.
“If we say we’re just going straight to church and back home, we should be fine,” Barry said. “There will be grownups going to church who can watch us.”
“I hate church. It’s so boring,” Stevie said. “I’d really like to not have to go.”
“We should do it,” Edward said, getting excited.
“That should be easy,” Chris said with a complacent shrug, even though he had been getting more excited as the conversation had progressed.
“What about your brothers, Gerard?” Nick said to me.
Robert and Peter could pose a problem. They were both in secondary school and resented me for being born so late. Robert, in particular, liked to make my life difficult.
I gave it a lot of thought. My brain had been whirling since Barry introduced the idea. Just like Stevie I found church boring. If we could have somehow done it without having to wear uncomfortable shirts, trousers, and tight dress shoes, I wouldn’t have hesitated.
“I think I can do it,” I said at last.
There was a moment of shock, as though none of us believed it would happen. Looking at Barry’s smile, he had looked more confident than the rest of us. A bunch of good little Catholic boys were going to dodge church.
•••
I got up that Sunday and was just coming out of the bathroom after taking a bath, to find Peter waiting for me. He was scowling.
“You’re up to something, you little shit,” he said.
I shook my head. I wasn’t confident I could say anything that wouldn’t give away my intentions. The uncanny knack I thought Peter had for knowing what I was doing was nothing more than guesswork I came to learn. We get on a lot better as adults, probably because we only talk a couple of times a year.
“Yes, you are. You and your wee mates have been making stupid fucking plans all week,” he said.
“Peter! What did I tell you about that kind of language,” our mum said as she appeared in the hall. “Your brother is going to church with his friends. I’ve talked to Stevie and Edward and Nicholas’s mums and they’re fine with it.”
“Why didn’t you let me do that when I was his age?”
“Because you couldn’t be trusted, son.”
He gaped at her. I had to suppress a giggle but given the nasty look he gave me I let a smirk escape.
“You were always trying to get one over on me and your dad at his age,” our mum said. “Gerard’s never done anything like that. He’s earned our trust.”
“But,” he said, whining.
“But nothing. Leave him alone to get dressed. You and Robert are coming with me and your dad.”
She ushered him into the bathroom while moving me towards my bedroom. I kept my head down, hiding my smile.
There’s not much else to say from that point. We did what any kids who had escaped from something we hated would do. We ran around, staying away from anywhere we might be spotted, mostly sticking to wooded areas of waste land, and went to Edward’s house when Nick said it was time.
Chris got a curious look from Edward’s mother because he hadn’t been able to contain himself and got so much dirtier than the rest of us from climbing trees and rolling around.
For two more weeks we did this. I got more nervous each time, and so did Stevie. The others became reckless, joining in with Chris in rough housing. Even Nick, the most reserved of us got caught up in the high spirits. I couldn’t. It got too much for me when Edward’s mother started asking pointed questions about the state of Nick’s, Barry’s, Chris’s and Edward’s clothes on that third visit.
“We’re going to get caught,” I said as we walked to school the following Monday.
“No we’re not,” Chris said.
“Edward’s mum is going to say something to my mum. I know it.”
“No she’s not,” Nick said.
“You were all covered in mud yesterday. Didn’t your mums wonder what you were doing?” I said.
“You are such a fucking downer, Gerard,” Chris said, trying out swearing for size. “I just said it happened on my way back home.”
“You’re always muddy. It doesn’t matter to your mum,” Stevie said. “Nick, Chris, and Barry’s mums must have noticed.”
“My mum and dad don’t care,” Barry said. “They wouldn’t even care if I didn’t come home from school.”
The rest of us exchanged awkward and embarrassed looks. Even Chris, with all his bravado was cowed by Barry’s tone. We all knew his parents cared more for his younger and older siblings, although even then I’d heard some parents use the word ‘neglect’ when discussing Barry’s home life and his siblings.
“You and Stevie are just a couple of babies,” Nick said. “Everything will be fine.”
“We aren’t being babies,” Stevie said. “I don’t like it anymore.”
I was about to add something when my attention was caught by a shape at the church.
Our route to school took us past the church. It might have been one of the reasons I was getting nervous about avoiding our Sunday visits. One day a priest might come out and ask us why we hadn’t been in so long. Being cornered by the clergyman would have been terrifying.
The priest who stood at the gate of the church grounds wasn’t one that I recognised. He was tall, dark haired and extremely thin. For some reason I couldn’t see his eyes. Despite that, he gazed at us hard, his mouth a thin, severe bow.
I was about to point him out, question who he was, when I saw the others were already staring at him. We all stood there for a while. I tried to make my voice work, but nothing would come. The questions were there, just as snarky and jokey as I wanted — and they stayed in my brain, as though the mechanisms for expression had been disconnected, shut off.
At last, he nodded slowly. When he walked away it was like the world around him distorted to accommodate him rather than his limbs moving. Like reality itself resisted him. He made his way to the church and entered.
We all looked at each other, pale and shocked. I still have the impression that they all wanted to say something, ask all the same questions I had. Except, perhaps for Barry, who continued to watch the closed church door. His expression I couldn’t read.
Blinking and looking around in confusion, my senses came back, and it looked like the others had the same experience. The other pedestrians and other children on the street didn’t notice anything had changed, so we continued on our way, in silence.
•••
I can’t remember if it was that same night or the following night. It might have been the following night because I’m sure Chris had been talking about seeing the tall priest the night before. We didn’t make anything of it, in fact we mocked him for how thin the lie was. Thinking back on it, he was genuinely upset.
Whichever night it was, I lay in bed awake, perhaps what Chris had said was more effective than I wanted to admit. It was late, I had listened to my parents go to bed and pretended to sleep as my brothers went to bed.
The house had been silent for over an hour before I couldn’t take it anymore and got out of bed. My room was at the back of the house and didn’t get quite as much light. The back garden was always dark, street light blocked off by buildings at all sides.
The priest’s white face stared up at me. Grim and eyeless, an uncompromisingly disapproving scowl glowering at me from the barrier of shadow. That face, his dog collar, and his hands crushed into fists floated in the darkness. I wanted to turn away, I wanted to scream. Being caught in his black glare stopped movement and sound. I have been mocked or condescended to throughout my life whenever I describe this, one of my ex-wives laughed at me every time I mentioned it. The fear and helplessness were shackles, tight and unyielding.
I don’t know what the signal was, but something prompted him to step away, the darkness swallowed him. Even as he retreated, I could see the shadows where his eyes should have been, holes punched in the normal darkness, for over a minute. I couldn’t move or make a sound before the deeper darkness finally faded. Unsteadily, I went back to bed and wept until sleep came.
Unlike Chris, I didn’t recount my experience for fear of being mocked. The way he looked at me for the rest of that day, I could see he knew what I had seen. Just as the next day, we both knew that Nick had been visited.
By the end of the week, we had all seen the priest, glaring in at us through our bedroom windows.
•••
Sunday arrived again, time, as always, ignoring all apprehensions. The others had come around to Stevie’s and my thoughts on going to church. Even Barry was willing to go back, in fact he was the first to bring it up after Stevie and myself made the suggestion.
I tried to be as quiet and unassuming as I could while we got ready to go out. My mother was surprised by my decision to return to the later service. Peter’s suspiciousness had only become stronger, he aggressively glared at me and elbowed me in the shoulder when neither of my parents were watching.
Otherwise, it was a normal morning preparing to leave for mass. Until we got to the church. Instead of the groups of people chatting on the path to the building, men stood in two formal groups at either side of the door. They all stared at me. One of them broke from the group as we entered the grounds and pulled my parents away.
“What have you done, you little shit?” Peter hissed in my ear.
I was too terrified to react. My parents looked aghast at first. I will never forget the look my mother gave me after a few more moments, the fury and the terror on her face. My father was stony-faced and held onto me, while my mother took Peter and Robert into the church.
The man signalled my father to follow. We were led into the narthex, where Barry, Nick, Stevie, Chris, and Edward waited. Stevie was already crying, and Chris looked as though he was about to join him. Nick looked scared but thoughtful and Edward looked confused. Barry let a small smile escape before he saw us, and his expression became neutral.
I was corralled with the other boys while my father was led away. His fear and worry hit me in such a deep way I wanted cry out for him, but the expressions of the other men stopped me.
The quiet in the church was like nothing else I had experienced. Only Stevie’s and Chris’s sobs interrupted it. No one moved. No one looked at us. The entire congregation faced the altar. The parish priest, Father Duffin, in full vestments, faced our direction, but I got the impression he wasn’t looking at us either.
“The Lord be with you,” he said, his voice crackling over the speakers.
“And also with you,” the congregation said, the familiar reply. Even through my fear I almost joined in.
“Our blessing and our succour have been forsaken.” I had never heard this before.
“Forsaken.” The reply was only taken up by a few of the assemblage.
“Let those who have turned their backs on us be brought forth. Let the Lord and Jesus Christ see them.”
Without a further word, we were pushed, as one, onto the nave. As we were forced down the middle of the church, I could feel the people around us try not to look. I couldn’t see my parents, but I saw Barry’s mother and father, watching in bafflement.
We were lined up in front of the altar. My hands were cold, and I was shivering. Even Stevie and Chris had stopped crying.
Father Duffin walked around the altar to us. It took me over twenty years to understand the expression he wore in that moment. He was conflicted. For what felt like hours he studied us.
“I’m sorry,” he whispered. He addressed the whole church. “You have shirked your duties and tried to hide your sins. It is now Father Imbution’s task to deal with you.”
He took a step back and looked in the direction of the sacristy. The silence this time was complete. I couldn’t even hear my pounding heart, as it juddered against my ribs.
When it happened, I knew what I was seeing and hoped that I was wrong. The distortion and resistance of the world, a section of the wall hiding the sacristy twisted. More of the wall altered in shape, the straight lines warped out of alignment. I heard gasps and mutters from the congregation that were quickly smothered.
His eyes, like wounds in the world seemed to appear first. Seething darkness that was able to see into us. The painful way air and masonry had to shift, to reconfigure to this entity’s presence made me want to recoil. Again, all of my reactions were circumvented, switched off and I was reduced to watching Father Imbution approach us.
Father Duffin bowed his head as Father Imbution passed. Father Imbution was two feet taller. I hadn’t expected him to have such a towering presence. Now, being so physically close, I was overwhelmed by the weight of his disapproval, his barely contained rage. Neither his skin nor his hair looked real, both had a translucent quality as though made from a jelly. Pale things whirled and quivered beneath the unnatural skin. The thin line of his mouth was open, and I saw the dark blocks of his teeth gritted and working back and forth.
“I have seen you in your sin and your deceit,” he said in a voice no human possessed. It rang through parts of my mind and body, settling and congealing. “This sin stains you deep in your soul. You must show the Lord you are back on the path. You must show the Lord you are contrite. A price must be paid.”
His words settled like poisoned rain on me, seeping further into my being. I was drenched in his acidic proclamation and strangled to silence. Despite everything around Father Imbution being tortured out of shape, there was no sound and he was still, like a still image from a children’s programme containing a graphic atrocity. His presence was smothering and uncompromising, even if my body hadn’t been paralysed, I was bereft of words.
“You want me,” Barry said, voice clear and unwavering. He stepped forward.
Even Father Duffin looked shocked. He shook his head in denial.
“You have the temerity to speak?” Father Imbution said.
“It was my idea. I persuaded my friends even when they didn’t want to do it,” Barry said, unaffected by the voice that sliced through me and held me in place like a butterfly specimen. He was smiling.
“You understand the price for such trespasses?”
Barry answered by holding out his hand. I wanted to bat his hand way, pull him to the ground. There was nothing within me that could overcome the paralysis. The paralysis that Barry somehow ignored.
Father Imbution considered the child’s proffered hand as though it were an alien thing of curious design. His anger seemed to increase, his teeth were no longer grinding, and I could see something pale grey roll and knot where a tongue should have been.
His long, thin fingers engulfed Barry’s slim, fragile hand. Where the strange skin touched it, Barry’s skin seemed to wither, turn grey. Barry didn’t react. He became so still, his face blank.
“You will come then,” Father Imbution said and turned his attention to us. “Confession for the rest of you.”
He dragged Barry away, back to the sacristy and out of everyone’s life. Neither Father Imbution nor Barry looked back. The distortion around Father Imbution extended to engulf and include Barry the further they went. My eyes watered in stinging pain before they went out of sight.
It would have been poetic to say there was nothing but silence in the church. There was no silence, the quiet sobbing sits in my mind when there is quiet. I’m forced to listen to my friends and adults I’d thought were immune to tears, sob in the wake of Father Imbution’s appearance.
Father Duffin looked stunned, he stared after the creature and the boy. His mouth worked with vague dumbness. I had never hated anyone like I hated him, his helpless expression was a catalyst for corrosive rage my small body could barely contain. There was nothing I could do, the unreasonable desire to lunge at him was quelled, not by my age, but by the weight of authority around me.
Someone spoke behind me, asking a question that broke Father Duffin’s trance. He nodded and we were dragged back into the pews to join our families. My brothers looked shocked and afraid — their teenage bravado demolished by what had happened. I saw no comfort from my parents, neither of them could look at me. A wall of tears tottered in my mother’s eyes and my father’s jaw was clenched and shuddering.
The mass that ensued was like a cascade of obliterating water. Much of the congregation might have said it was purifying, as the confusion and fear were scrubbed away by the familiar chants. I felt sullied, and I didn’t even understand such a concept.
No amount of call and response, scripted worship would unglue the questions that filled my head. They scrabbled like trapped rodents, clawing and scraping for an escape.
“What’s going to happen to Barry?” I said when we were halfway home.
Neither of my parents acknowledged me. They heard me. The memory of them exchanging a glance is clear as that whole morning. They stared ahead, fixated on getting home, without breaking breath.
“Mum, Dad. What happened to him?” my voice quivered this time. Most of it was frustration, but there was a shimmering halo of fear.
Silence rewarded my persistence. I was discouraged from saying anything else by my father’s infuriated expression. My mother sniffed, but she had turned enough to obscure whether she was crying.
Most of the rest of that day I spent in my room, sent in there the moment we got back home. Despite glowering at me whenever he could, Peter avoided me. Robert looked sad, he still does on the rare occasions we are all together, we have never been close and that day it seemed we drifted further.
•••
No one would talk about it. I was the only one who showed any curiosity about what we had all witnessed. Nothing I could do would get anything from them. Stevie was the first to stop talking to any of us, he looked faintly afraid of us until we were split up further in secondary school. Edward became distant soon after almost as though he had been looking for an excuse to break away from us. Chris, ever the contrarian started hanging around with a bunch of Protestant kids and became actively hostile to us. I couldn’t blame him or any of them for their reactions.
Only Nick and I would hang around with each other until the end of primary seven. We might not have if Nick hadn’t become serious a year after Barry’s disappearance, he looked so much older than nine that day. I had been talking about Barry again, after his family moved away.
“You can’t keep doing this, Gerard,” he said.
I feigned ignorance and stared at him blankly.
“We aren’t going to get answers. The questions you keep asking are just making people angry.” He sighed, as though he had seen the future. “If you keep going, you’ll end up alone. There’s already so much happened. You have to let it go.”
I had no answer. No argument. He was right, and I followed his advice for a while. It was well into secondary school when I couldn’t contain it anymore. I wonder if we had been in the same friend group in the bigger school, he might have been able to quell my need. Perhaps, instead of becoming indifferent, he would have developed hatred for me. He’s the only one who still acknowledges me as an adult, nodding and smiling when we pass each other in the street. The others might as well be strangers, I recognise them, but they look right through me.
Sometimes it makes me wonder if I am an actual ghost.
#The moment I left home I stopped going to church, ignoring my mother’s nagging and cajoling. Even as a man over forty, I expect to see Father Imbution again, waiting to punish me for forsaking the church. Perhaps I want to be punished.
William Couper (he/him) is a writer from Scotland. As well as horror, he writes fantasy, and science fiction. He will even do some non-fiction when the fancy takes him and has had work appear on Gingernuts of Horror. His fiction has featured in anthologies including, Cthulhu Lies Dreaming, In the Blink of an Eye, and Built from Human Parts, as well as the periodicals, Penumbric Speculative Fiction Magazine, Cosmic Horror Monthly, The Horror Zine, Black Sheep Magazine and Schlock Webzine.